Night of Threes - three contestants, three songs, 3 call-in lines each contestant, and three judges. The three song selections chosen by: an idol judge, producers, and contestant.
I am looking forward to tonight’s performances – each contestant left has been a favorite of mine to watch this season. I’m not sure how I’m going to vote tonight!
(Click the idol talk button for more reviews)
Round #1 – Judges’ Choice
Jordin – Simon selected “Wishing on a Star” by Rose Royce
Jordin’s voice was smoking with this selection. I’m not familiar with the original version of this song, but I thought her vocals were smooth and showed how flexible her voice is. I wish I could sing like that at 17 and get up on a stage and make it look that easy. Heck, I couldn’t even record a vocal performance tape for my music scholarship which annoyed my parents who were saving for my college bill. But, I digress…
Contrary to Simon’s personal taste, I enjoyed the jazzy, sultry arrangement. I thought it completely suited Jordin’s voice and style.
Blake – Paula’s choice was “Roxanne” by The Police
Wow, for such a distinctive song, I thought Blake pulled it off. DH and I are huge Police fans. The phrasing sounded “off” from the original, but seeing Blake perform in his element made up for it. This song choice really showcased Blake’s singing voice. The boy has some power in those vocal chords. When he is confident and performing a song he likes, Blake is great to watch.
Melinda – Randy picked “I Believe in You and Me” by Whitney Houston
Such a challenging song with tremendous range. Did the song sound a key too low at the beginning? Or maybe she’s a little nervous outside of her comfort zone. DH just commented that the transitions were pretty difficult. Nonetheless, Melinda’s vocals were beautiful and she always sings with so much heart and feeling. She looked/sounded a little unsure of herself, but the judges loved it anyway.
Round #2 – Producers’ Choice
Jordin – “She Works Hard for the Money” by Donna Summer
An energetic song to match Jordin’s personality. The lyrics were odd for her to be singing, but she sings with the conviction to pull it off. I liked her ending and that she changed it up to be more current.
Blake – “This Love” Maroon 5
I loved this song selection and was so excited to hear Blake perform! I actually did a little TV Junkie dance when they announced this choice. His rendition had the perfect amount of beatboxing and still maintained the original sound and vibe of the song. I was totally loving it and loving Blake during this performance.
Melinda – “Nut Bush City Limits” Ike & Tina Turner
Melinda was rocking out. How cute to see her pick up the mic stand and let loose. I’m disappointed that the song selection was quite repetitive, but Melinda still knew how to make it work like the professional she is. The girl just sang a Tina Turner song and completely owned it.
Round #3 – Singers’ Choice
Jordin – “I, Who Have Nothing”
For a 17-year-old, Jordin sings and performs like a pro. She is talented, has personality and the “Yo” factor – the total package. No doubt she is headed for a wonderful career.
Blake – “When I Get You Alone” Robin Thicke
You have to love when the contestants can choose their own song. Blake picked a hot song and had a hot performance. I was melting when he sang “Baby Girl, where are you” – who me?!? Just call me a Blaker Girl.
I had gotten bored with Blake’s performances because they lacked the original spark that made him fresh and original, but tonight he finally has a chance to really show off his style. {wink wink} psst… Blake, call me 
btw, did anyone else see Nigel (one of the producers) getting down to this song? ROFL!
Melinda – “I am Woman”
Another stellar performance. Melinda is so consistent. I’m sure other record producers are hoping she won’t win so they could snatch her up for their own label. No matter what, I’m a fan for life.
I can’t decide who should stay and who should go! Do you have a favorite?? Who would you send home?
By TVJunkie Jenn