TV Shows I Like » American Idol

American Idol Top 11 (3-18-08)

Posted: March 18th, 2008 | American Idol, Lakisha Jones

Back with The Beatles!

“I see you’re holding signmaker seminars at your house again” – Ryan to Simon, after a shot of a Simon is Sexy sign in the audience

Amanda Overmeyer
Most Memorable Moment: Playing on the big stage last week
“Back in the USSR”

Amanda gave an upbeat, original performance. She has such a distinctive voice, that it can sound the same from week to week. I enjoy her down-to-earth personality.

Perfect sound choice for you… a little pitchy, but you worked it out halfway through. I give you a 7 out of 10. It was good! – Randy
It was a little sketchy at first… a little ahead of the beat… quintessential, authentic who you are. I love you and I think you are going to continue going up – Paula
It was what it was. A bit predictable… do something a bit of a surprise… otherwise you are in danger of becoming a bit boring – Simon

Kristy Lee Cook
Most Memorable Moment: Being the last man standing at each results show
“You Have to Hide Your Love Away”

Kristy has a strong and warm-sounding voice, but a little pitchy… maybe nervous

It was an interesting arrangement… it should have been more emotional for you… the high note at the end was good – Randy
On some of these songs you have to be careful about the melody… this is the best you’ve looked – you look gorgeous… it was a little safe and it was good. I agree with Randy on the high notes and you should take liberties more often – Paula
I think you need something like hypnosis… you’re not a good performer… it’s like musical wallpaper – you notice it but you don’t remember it – Simon

I can blow you out of your socks and you know it – Kristy to Simon

David Archuletta
Most Memorable Moments: Being able to sing “Imagine”… not so good moment – forgetting his lyrics
“The Long and Winding Road”

David has such a smooth sounding voice and he knows how to work the crowd with his emotions. It’s easy to see why he’s such a favorite. He’s a gifted and talented singer. I thought it was a great song choice and fit for his voice.

David has brought the hotness back to his game… one piece of advice… you can do a couple runs… you played it safe, but you can take liberties – Randy
This is the most exciting and wonderful performance because the purity… came back strong… you came back from adversity – Paula
Last week was a complete mess.. this week I thought you were amazing… absolutely you made my point… sell a song… and remember a performance… that was a master class – Simon

[insert at&t and iphone spot here]

Michael Johns
Most Memorable Moment: Hollywood week when he sang Bohemian Rhapsody – absolutely magic!
“A Day in the Life”

Another classy performance from Michael. He picked it in tribute to his friend who passed away last year – it was his friend’s favorite song.

You know what I’m going to say… I don’t think you’ve chosen the right song… you’ve got that big ol voice… just sing and let your voice do your thing – Randy
You were pretty phenomenal [in rehearsal]… – Paula
It was a mess… you didn’t hit the right notes… it doesn’t work as a minute in a half… you have to hit the song like David before you. It was not good enough – Simon

Brooke White
Most Memorable Moment: singing and performing “Let it be”
“Here Comes the Sun”

This was one of my favorite songs as a child and thought Brooke did an okay job.

Yo, That performance was really awkward. You were never really connected to the song. It was not hot for me – Randy
You can’t help but smile when you sing. I love the yellow for the sun. You have really good low tones. It could have been a little more challenging. Brooke, you are a lovable girl – Paula
I thought the performance was terrible. From the horrible dancing, to the absolute lack of connection. There is a huge difference between Let it be and Here comes the sun – Simon

David Cook
Most Memorable Moment: Last Tuesday, having that rock concert feel with the lights and fog… what the judges said about his performance was the icing on the cake
“Daytripper” (which was also performed by Whitesnake)

David has such a big voice – perfect for his rock songs. He looks like such a natural on stage as he feeds off of the crowd.

You keep it interesting. Another solid look for David Cook – Randy
You’re ready to go sell records. You chose using the voice box in a very cool way – Paula
I don’t think that was as good as you thought it was. You looked a bit smug throughout. …predictable – Simon

Carly Smithson
Most Memorable Moment: Being compared to Kelly Clarkson last week for the second time (first was during her very first audition)
“Blackbird”

Tough transitions in this song and a very wide range. Even though it was a slow song, it was still moving to me

Another great performance. Very nice, very controlled, very emotive… cooliosis right there – Randy
You have an amazing tone in your voice, the inflections that you do, the choices that you make, the arrangement was beautiful. You stand in there with a capital F for Fantastic – Paula
I don’t think that [song choice] was a very smart thing to do. I thought the song was indulgent. I didn’t like the song at all – Simon

Jason Castro
Most Memorable Moment: When he sang Hallelujah… it was a bad last note, but nobody cared
“Michelle”

Song is a great fit for his range and his French pronunciation seems spot-on. I thought it would be a corny song choice, but it turned out okay for me.

Good choice. A little interesting. It is very subdued from you this week – Randy
You have a very distinct charm about you. I feel like you get a little disconnected when you’re away from your guitar. It was a little awkward for me. It didn’t connect with the audience – Paula
This is a very weird show tonight. Your face sold that. What you have, and I like you a lot, you’re very charming and you’re not obnoxious. Your kind of goofiness that makes it work – Simon

Syesha Mercado
Most Memorable Moment: Losing her voice during Hollywood and being in the bottom three last week
“Yesterday” [almost named Scrambled Eggs before Yesterday was picked]

Love when there’s a solo instrumentalist on stage. It started a little safe, but Syesha powered it up halfway through. I like that she did a slower tempo piece to show off her range and versatility.

So you took some liberties. In my estimation, very very very good performance tonight – Randy
It’s great to see how you change and let yourself be vulnerable. That vulnerability is where you need to be. Connect more with your eyes and audience. You got a beautiful instrument – Paula
I thought that was probably your best performance so far. It wasn’t incredible. But you chose the best song. You chose the song Brooke should have sung. I like the arrangement and I thought you sold the song very well – Simon

Chikezie
Most Memorable Moment: My first round of Hollywood. That was the first time he got a compliment from all three judges.
“I’ve Just Seen a Face”

Chikezie has a silky smooth voice. Then, he changed it up and picked up the tempo of the song to play to the crowd.

There were some good parts and some bad parts… I like it when you went to the fast part. The slow part I didn’t quite get. You need that fast stuff for all the energy you got. Harmonica was a weird strange arrangement, but could be a good country song – Randy
I disagree [with Randy]. You’re showing who you are. You’re showing who you are and the depth and scope of your vocals. When you sing… it is so pure, on pitch, beautiful – Paula
I thought it started off okay, and then you played the harmonica… atrocious… and then it turns into achy, breaky heart in the end. It was gimmicky – Simon

hmmm… without “achy, breaky heart”, we might not have America’s favorite – Hannah Montana…

Ramiele Malubay
Most Memorable Moment: Making a whole bunch of new friends. “You get closer to them, because you’re stuck with them. Brooke is like the mom of the apartment and David Cook is like the big brother. It’s like a big family.”
“I Should Have Known Better”

I wasn’t jumping up and down, but I liked it. You showed that confidence… it was a happy-go lucky kind of joint. You did your thing, it was alright – Randy
Definitely better than last week. There is something about your voice when you sing ballads, that allows you to show your range – Paula
It sounded like Chikezie was on the harmonica. I like you a lot. The track sounded horrible. You, along with many others, chose really mediocre songs and didn’t show the best of your ability – Simon

My favorite of the night: Syesha Mercado and David Cook

Un-favorite of the night: Kellie Pickler (oops that’s tomorrow)

Click on post title to read more.

By TVJunkie Jenn | Comments Off
Filed under: American Idol, Lakisha Jones

American Idol Top 12 (3-11-08)

Posted: March 11th, 2008 | American Idol

Look at that stage – Bigger and better than ever! The band has it’s own “penthouse” and there’s a mosh pit. And, hey look, Simon isn’t wearing black or grey.

Theme: Lennon/McCartney songbook

Syesha Mercado

“Got To Get You Into My Life” 1966

I thought Syesha looked a little nervous and had a couple pitchy notes to start, but once she warmed up she “worked it out” as Randy would say…

Nice arrangement. Started a little rough, but by the middle you kind of got into it and had fun with it… it was a’ight for me – Randy
It started off pitch but midway through you found your zone – Paula
I thought it was better than alright Randy. I thought it was a great choice of song…. you looked very, very nervous – Simon

Chikezie

“She’s a Woman”

Used to work security at LAX and grew up listening to Nigerian tunes. Banjo, violin, tambourine to start off. I thought his take was original and fun!

Dog, I was thouroughly entertained. Who knew? I love the arrangement… Chikezie smashed it! – Randy
You started with the “O Brother Where Out Thou” vibe then turned it into the rock vibe. I’ve been waiting for this. The reward paid off, my dear – Paula
I’m really surprised I actually agree with these two. (huge cheering from Chikeze, Cuba Gooding Jr. emmy-style) Other than the fact that you looked completely drunk. You’ve really changed within a week. – Simon

Ramiele

“I pour soy sauce in little cups.” She works at a restaurant! Come on Ramiele… represent for all the Filipinas. You have an awesome voice, I wish you would let everyone hear it!

“In My Life”

Makes singing seem so effortless.

It was kinda pretty, but it was kinda pretty boring to me.
You look really pretty tonight. It was pretty safe… you need to take advantage of that. I feel like you are holding back
“The whole world should see what we hear” – Simo, quoting Paula
I was bored to tears… dreary song choice that did absolutely nothing for you. I expect a lot better from you because you’re better than that.

Jason Castro

Texas A&M, music minor… but it was the only class he failed. Family is from Columbia. They didn’t know English, but knew The Beatle’s music.

“If I Fell”

Guitar is back. It’s a slow song, but a good song choice for Jason’s tone.

I liked it. I didn’t love it. The switches in the melody for me, I found myself kind of tuning out – Randy
I disagree wtih Randy. What is so special and unique about you, I feel your heart. You don’t do the riffs and runs and you don’t have to – Paula
Last week you were incredible, this it was all a little bit student in a bedroom at midnight (wha?) I thought the song was quite boring. Very unique. Very big fan of Jason…. choose brilliant songs that suit your style – Simon

Carly Smithson

Orange juice, eggs, celery

“Come Together”

Such an interesting sound to her voice.

So Carly, that felt amazing didn’t it. You were strong, you were confident, you were having a good time, you sounded there wasn’t a note out of tune. stellar performance. – Randy
I felt like I was already watching a star. I couldn’t wait until you were in the top 12 you can really start showing who you are as a performer – Paula
Week after week, I think you have chosen the wrong song… until now. This reminds me, six years ago, exactly the same week… Kelly Clarkson.

David Cook

green fingernail polish

Eleanor Rigby - the goal is to leave it on the stage

You can definitely rock out on idol, you can rock out on The Beatles. It was rocking. Let it go – Randy
I’ve been telling everyone you’re the dark horse. You are a thoroughbred. We all know you are the frontman on your band. You are the frontman here – Paula
David, I thought it was brilliant. For two weeks now, Paula’s right. If this show remains a talent competition, and not a popularity competition, you may actually win this show – Simon

Brooke White

“Let It Be”

Playing from memory and singing is a challenge! I always did one or the other, but not both

I don’t know if it’s your best performance. I imagine you growing up playing that song at home… This is your dream come true, isn’t it …very heartfelt performance. I’m a fan – Randy
This is your niche. Picking songs where America can feel your heart. It is having that emotional connection that makes people fall in love with you – Paula
Again, one of the best performances of the night. I thought it was a brilliant choice of song… It’s believeable. There’s a difference between karaoke and showcasing your talent – Simon

David Hernandez

“I Saw Her Standing There”

Beatles 101 – an actual class at Arizona State

Energetic performance.

You’ve got a big voice, but on a song like this, it was a little bit overdone – Randy
I feel like you kindof overdid it. I think you scale back. You’re a brilliant singer and… not too many runs (waves hands) – Paula
No. No. No. Corny verging on desperate. I thought it was a little rabbit in the headlights. I didn’t think it was a particularly strong performance – Simon

Amanda Overmyer

“You Can’t Do That”

Amanda-spin, Rock it up a bit

That is the true mark of great songs. You took a beatles song and brought it to a southern bar and rocked it out – Randy
Amanda you’re smiling, you’re a star up there. I’m blown away by you – Paula
I don’t think it was as good as last week and I understood about 30% of what you said. I think it is a good thing that you’re in this competition – you’re like a breath of fresh air – Simon

Michael Johns

“Across the Universe”

I was waiting for something big for me. A little sleepy for me – Randy
I disagree with you again, Randy. It takes an inner strength and inner confidence… it was a brilliant performance – Paula
I’m going to agree with Randy. It was solid. It was good. But now is the time to let it go a little bit – Simon
Go Big, Baby, Go Big! – Randy

Kristy Lee Cook

“Eight Days a Week”

Oy, those violins kept me awake. I almost started hyperventilating.

I actually like the arrangement and the idea of the song… I’m kinda torn with this one… half of me likes it, half of me doesn’t – Randy
Kristy, I didn’t enjoy it. I didn’t get it
I thought it was horrendous. You sounded like Dolly Parton on helium. It was a very brave, but probably foolish thing to do – Simon

David Archuletta

His mom is from Honduras and his dad is a jazz musician. He’s second oldest with an older brother and three sisters.

“We Can Work It Out”

Halfway through, he looked a little shaken, but David still gave a good performance

This week it was not on point. This is not your vibe.
This wasn’t your best week, but you’re a front runner… Never let it show on your face… we love ya – Paula
That was a mess, you stumbled over the lyrics… it was just all over the place. It was your weakest performance so far – Simon

Best of the Night - ummm, Carly, Chikezie, Brooke, David Cook

Least Favorite of the Night - Kristy Lee Cook (sorry, not a country fan), Syesha (I forgot she started off the night until I saw the closing recap)

Click on post title to read more.

By TVJunkie Jenn | 2 Comments »
Filed under: American Idol

American Idol Top 8 Women (3-5-08)

Posted: March 5th, 2008 | American Idol

80s Night! Most Embarassing Moments

Asia’h Epperson

“I Wanna Dance With Somebody” – Whitney Houston

I recorded that great song with the great Whitney… tall order, but.. you showed and proved you should be here – Randy
You nailed it! You really nailed it! – Paul
I’m not quite so enthusiastic. At best, it was second rate – Simon
No Pitch Patrol from Randy – Ryan

Kady Malloy

“Who Wants To Live Forever” – Queen

Embarrassing Moment: Bombed on Christina and did the classic speaker feedback…

Um, I say this every time, don’t the contestants know Queen songs are some of the most difficult song choices? This piece has some difficult transitions! The slower tempo also makes any pitch problems noticeable. A double-whammy to overcome… let’s see what the judges say…

You hit the big notes well, but didn’t support the smaller notes – Randy
To date, best performance – Paula
Definitely better than last week, but I’m having issues with your massive lack of personality… I got no emotion out of this – Simon

Amanda Overton

“I Hate Myself For Loving You” – Joan Jett

Embarrassing moment: Fireplace on deck… burned down a pool. Burned down a pool?!

Now that’s the Amanda we loved when we first saw her… well done, baby – Randy
When you pick the right song, you’ve found your niche – Paula
If I’m being honest, I thought it was fantastic. I thought you absolutely nailed that song, it was the perfect It was one of my favorite girl performances of this part of the show – Simon

Carly Smithson

“I Drove All Night” - Celine

Embarrassing Moment: got leg stuck in railing while on break from work. greased

Yo Carly, you keep smashing it. Very very good. Another great performance – Randy
You are like a dependable dog… I think you’re totally into your niche.
I don’t think you chose the right song… sorry… I just didn’t like it. It’s just not a great song… you’re a million times better than that song – Simon
She still sang it well – Randy

Kristy Lee Cook

“Faithfully” – Journey

Embarrassing Moment: 7 years old – used to pretend she was a dog, pet rats, water bowl, she thought she was a dog

I can’t believe I still remember this song word for word. Great song.

Dogs. and Journey. I love this girl…. great song, great band. What was cool, you put a country spin to it – Randy
That could be a hit for you in country music. I have nothing but positivity for you – Paula
I still think your problem is that you’re forgettable – Simon

Ramiele Malubay

“Take a Look at Me Now” - Phil Collins

Embarrassing Moment: 5th grade, dropped off picture

Another big song… Come on wit it – Randy
You have a lot of colors texture to your voice. You deserve to be in the top 12 – Paula
Because you’re so little and cute, it was good. But it was very old fashioned… predictable – Simon

Brooke White

“Love is a Battlefield” – Pat Benatar

Embarrassing Moment: Hugged a strange man

Love the acoustic guitar – you can really focus on her voice (I typed that before Randy said the same lol). Emotion and conviction in her face made this such a great performance.

I don’t know that you brought anything new to that song – Randy
I thought it was a very wise choice. I like the fact that it was very pure… -Paula
I think it worked purely for the reason [that it was acoustic] – Simon

Sayesha Mercado

“I’m Saving All My Love” – Whitney Houston

Good. Good – Randy
Sophisticated. Lovely – Paula
Predictable but good – Simon

Closing comments –

The girls worked it out. They did their thang tonight – Randy
I don’t want to see anyone go – Paula
You weren’t anywhere near the guys. My favorite performance was Amanda (Overmyer) tonight – Simon

Click on post title to read more.

By TVJunkie Jenn | Comments Off
Filed under: American Idol

American Idol Top 8 Men (3-4-08)

Posted: March 4th, 2008 | American Idol

It’s 80′s Night & Embarrassing Moments (all photos from americanidol.com)

Luke Menard
“Wake Me Up Before Go-Go” - Wham! George Michael

Embarrassing Moment: 8 year old – dressed like a ballerina and took photos

You were kinda rushing it, but you found it. You did good. It was kind of corny – Randy
I was kind of surprised you picked that song. I loved it – Paula
I didn’t like it. I thought it was weak. It was kind of girly… It wasn’t very good. Sorry – Simon

David Archuletta
“Another Day in Paradise” - Phil Collins

Embarrassing Moment: Honduras… mom finished song for him

Played piano

It was like watching you in concert. Didn’t show off your vocal prowess, but it was nice – Randy
You’re perfectly wonderful for this competition – Paula
It wasn’t as good as last week…. You gotta lighten up a bit… you’re probably going to be in the final two – Simon

Danny Noriega
“Tainted Love” – Soft Cell

Embarrassing Moment: Friend tripped him and he turned as red as a cute little tomato. TMTH!

I love the arrangement. I love that conviction. He’s got all the mad attitude for everyone in the place -
You are like this bright light in this competition. Sensitive… spicy… I love the fact that you’re true to yourself – Paula
I thought it was horrible, the whole thing. Absolutely useless. Hated the _____ (fill in the blank, Simon probably said it) – Simon

David Hernandez
“All Coming Back to Me Now” - Celine

Embarrassing Moment: During a photo shoot there was a pea-sized booger in his nose!

Nice song choice for you… a little pitch voice… but you got that big ol voice – Randy
I feel like you’re getting into your groove. you’re becoming a good performer – Paula
Oh, I Love You – David
It wasn’t as good as last week, but you’ve 100% secured a place in the finals – Simon

Michael Johns

“Don’t You Forget About Me” - Simple Minds

Embarrassing Moment: Mascot work – Kangaroo for a rugby match 20,000 people

Nice one – Randy
You’re defining who you are. You picked a perfect song. And I loved hearing the strength in your low range. You have this presence… and hopping… – Paula
I liked it. Huge talent but haven’t quite connected with the right song. I really, really like you and I think you’re going to do well in this competition – Simon

David Cook
“Hello” - Lionel Richie

Embarrassing Moment: Talent show as a child singing Sandman – and forgot the 2nd verse

Very interesting take on Lionel Richie. I liked it – very original.

What I love… you made a slightly emo version of a very pop, EXTREMELY POP song. Great arrangement. I think that could be a single and be a hit. Brilliant – Randy
I totally love when you come on the stage… that was fabulous. That would be a hit today. You make perfect choices – Paula
That was a very brave thing to do and I. Luhved. It. I like people who go out there and take a few risks. I think Lionel Richie would be happy with that…. I was in the grocery store with Lionel Richie on Sunday… True Story – Simon

Jason Castro
“Hallelujah” - Jeff Buckley

Embarrassing Moment: On a date, he tied his hair back and lost a dread, but still scored another date.

Great degree of difficulty. You did a pretty good job of it, but I give you props for it. – Randy
You made it sound so effortless. I’m so glad you showed a great vulnerability. Jason, you are exactly what I love about this season. you are unique. Your phrasing sets you apart – Paula
I thought it was absolutely brilliant. One of my favorite performances of the night. You’re getting better and better and better. – Simon

Chikezie
“All the Woman That I Need” - Whitney

When starting HS, he would always retreat to a quiet, empty restroom for a comfort stop. Then he found out… it was a women’s restroom

Ryan: Paula, can you sum up the show in one word?

Paula: Two Words. Phe-nomenal

Ryan: Let’s not do the math. Simon, in 10 seconds, can you reply to that?

Simon: How can I reply to those wise words?

Click on post title to read more.

By TVJunkie Jenn | Comments Off
Filed under: American Idol

American Idol Top 10 Women (2-26-08)

Posted: February 27th, 2008 | American Idol

Carly Smithson, 24
San Diego, CA
“‘Crazy on You” - Heart

You would be surprised to know… she works at an Irish bar. Loves her house, loves to clean, loves to cook. Being on stage is her next favorite place to be.

I wasn’t crazy about the song, but Carly can belt out the tunes so it didn’t really matter.

So you came out the rocker this week… By the middle of the song you got it together – Randy
It’s great to see that you’re healthy. It takes a fine singer to sing Heart… you are an amazing singer – Paula
It was a much better performance than last week… you’re panting! I think you are… I’ll put it on record… an incredible singer. Once she finds the right song and connects, she can be the one to beat. – Simon

Sayesha Mercado, 21
Sarasota, FL
“Me & Mr. Jones” – Billy Paul

People would be surprised to know… Sayesha’s done a lot of commercials locally. Then, she broke out with the fake baby cry.

Sayesha girl, you’ve got voice. Use it!

Pick stuff that you can use… that was just a taste of what you’ve got – Randy
Those softer notes… you fall off pitch – Paula
I thought it was a bit indulgent. It doesn’t… (boos from the crowd)… I was put off… it’s not a song designed for your voice… not a clever choice for you – Simon

Brooke White, 24
Mesa, AZ
“You’re So Vain” – Carly Simon

Brook’s big secret is that she is a beauty school drop-out. She walks around, looking at people, wondering “what can I do with their hair?”

Carly was a perfect choice for Brooke – showing off her rich, lower register. How charming with the guitar. “She was looking at me while she was performing” – Simon

Great song choice for you… you have a great Carly Simon vibe – Randy
This was a perfect song choice. It totally suits you. Everyone was digging it – Paula
I absolutely loved it. The absolute perfect song… The artist genuinely picked the right song – Simon

Debating whether using the guitar – smart choice from the judges.

Ramiele Malubay, 20
Miramar, FL
“Don’t Leave Me This Way” - Thelma Houston

Ramiele started Polynesian hula dancing at a young age and has been hula dancing and Filipino dancing for 12 years.

This was a little rough… just okay for me vocally. Wasn’t my favorite choice for you… keeping it real – Randy
Your vocals are really amazing… I feel the same way… you didn’t get to perform your magic. With that said, ou truly are one of the best – Paula
Astonishingly I agree with Paula. Much more interesting last week I think you’re one of the top 3 singers in the competition – Simon

Kristy Lee Cook, 24
Selma, OR
“You’re No Good” – Linda Ronstadt

I’m a tomboy, I enjoy being outside and getting dirty – fishing, softball, athletics, camp, ride horses.

All I can tell you is Better song choice. I was looking for some breakout moments. In tune. I liked it – Randy
You’re Back! It was a real good song choice for you – Paula
It was a huge improvement, but I’m not sure where to label you… but you’ve got real potential – Simon

Amanda Overmeyer, 23
Mulberry, IN
” – Kansas

Most people know she rides a harley… she likes to read biographies… can’t ever be overeducated… good form of

There were too many instrumental breaks. Not quite the right song for you… keep it bluesy-rock – Randy
You’ve got some moves! You can dance. Do what fits right and what feels right. You are needed in this competion… this was not the right song for you – Paula
Everything felt contrived. None of it felt natural or real… I couldn’t wait for it to finish – Simon

Alaina Whitaker, 16
Tulsa, OK
“Hopelessly Devoted to You” - Olivia Newton-John

I don’t like the food on my plate to touch each other. flowing green bean juice.

Contrived, pitchy – sounded like she was yelling.

Uh… I like that song… I don’t think that was the right song for you… Wasn’t my favorite for you – Randy
I forget how young you are and how mature you are – Paula
I like you, my problem is, it’s almost as if your grandmother prepared you… your hair, your dress… It was all a bit pagenty… I think you’re the dark horse… become relevant – Simon

Alexandrea Lushington, 17
Douglasville, GA
“If You Leave Me Now” – Chicago

poster child for the fire department. Sang at ground zero after 9-11

Good interpretation at the end

What’d you think? It was just so safe for you. You should always challenge yourself – Randy
You did your own arrangement, stretched it, and made it your own. I’ve been impressed with you from Day 1 – Paula
I was a big big fan of yours. I think your struggling right now. The song is stuck in its time song. You look terrific, but the song didn’t feel right for you – Simon

Kady Malloy, 18
Houston, TX
“Magic Man” – Heart

Kady sings rigaletto, singing opera since 9 years old. Loves to sing opera in the bathroom.

I don’t get this performance. The song didn’t sound remotely familiar.

You never found the notes. It didn’t work – Randy
When you powered, it sounded great. Low notes were off a bit. You sing opera very well. Really define yourself as the artist you are – Paula
I’m very, very frustrated… opera was very good… (music cuts him off again) There’s a charm about her on the tape – Simon

Asia’h Epperson, 19 with extensions
Joplin, MO
“All By Myself” – Celine

Asia’h was a cheerleader in middle school and high school – make cheers and do dances… go to camps.. go out there and get the crowd into it. Prepared her for idol.

Very difficult song. Highest degree of difficulty… you did a good job with it – Randy
We had problems in the low notes, but the ending, that’s where it matters – Paula
One of the diva songs of all time. You have to be one heck of a singer. Unfortunately, you’re not. You almost got away with it… – Simon